Deer Park, NY
Client portal coming soon
Our online client portal is on the way. In the meantime, our team is happy to help — just reach out.
Contact us
Almost no employer is penalized for refusing to offer COBRA. They are penalized for offering it late, describing it imprecisely, mailing it to the wrong address, or forgetting a dependent. COBRA liability is procedural — and that makes it manageable.
COBRA exposure is created by missed deadlines and defective notices, not by bad intentions. Every obligation is a clock that starts on a specific date and must be documented: 90 days for the general notice, 30 days for the employer’s notice of a qualifying event, 14 days for the election notice — 44 days where you are also the plan administrator — then 60 days to elect and 45 more to pay. Because notices are templated, a single content defect is inherently classwide, with statutory penalties running per beneficiary per day. New York adds a second layer: continuation to a total of 36 months on insured plans regardless of employer size. If you can prove what was sent, to whom, on what date, and to what address, you have resolved most of your COBRA risk before it becomes a dispute.
The Consolidated Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act requires most group health plans to offer temporary continuation of coverage to employees and family members who would otherwise lose it because of a specified life event. The concept is simple. The administration is not — and the administration is where the money is.
Liability is procedural, not substantive. A single election notice that omits required content, or is written in language a typical participant cannot follow, can support a class action on behalf of every terminated employee who received the same form. The exposure is rarely about one claim; it is about one template used hundreds of times.
Three agencies share jurisdiction, which is why one failure can generate more than one penalty. The Department of Labor administers the notice and disclosure provisions under Title I of ERISA and publishes the model notices. The IRS administers the excise tax under Internal Revenue Code section 4980B. HHS administers COBRA as it applies to state and local government plans. Participants also have a private right of action.
Every obligation is a clock. Each one starts on a specific triggering date, runs for a specific number of days, and must be documented. That framing — clocks and evidence rather than rules and intentions — is the single most useful way to organize a COBRA program.
The burden is on the plan to show a notice was sent — not that it was received. What wins disputes is credible evidence of a consistent mailing procedure and of this particular mailing: recipient, address used, date generated, date mailed, and the template version. An archived image of the exact notice sent beats a copy of the current template every time.
Federal COBRA applies to a group health plan maintained by an employer that had 20 or more employees on more than 50 percent of its typical business days in the preceding calendar year. The count is of employees, not participants — an employee who declined coverage still counts — and part-time staff count as a fraction. Controlled groups are aggregated, so related companies under common ownership are counted together even where each entity is small on its own.
Each qualified beneficiary elects separately. A spouse may elect even if the employee declines; a 22-year-old dependent may elect even if both parents decline. Notices must be addressed so every beneficiary actually receives one.
A child born or adopted during the continuation period acquires beneficiary status. A new spouse married during the period may be added under special enrollment, but is not a qualified beneficiary and has no independent election right.
A single notice to the employee’s home is treated as notice to the spouse and dependents at that address — but only if the plan’s records show that address. This is why dependent-level records matter more than they appear to.
Domestic partners and non-tax-dependent children are typically not qualified beneficiaries federally. Many employers extend a parallel right by plan design — document it in the plan document and SPD so it is administered consistently.
COBRA applies to plans that provide medical care. Whether a benefit counts depends on what it pays for, not what it is called. Major medical, dental, vision, and HRAs are subject. A health FSA is subject but limited — no offer is required where the account is overspent. An EAP is covered if it diagnoses or treats rather than merely referring; an on-site clinic generally is, unless services are limited to first aid. Telehealth and wellness arrangements should be evaluated by function: biometric screening with clinical follow-up is medical care. Life, AD&D, and disability are not. The HSA itself is individually owned and not subject — but the underlying HDHP is.
COBRA compliance is a relay. Each participant in the chain has a deadline, and a failure at any handoff extends or restarts the clocks downstream.
From the plan administrator to the covered employee and covered spouse, within 90 days after coverage begins. Send separately to the spouse where the spouse's address of record differs.
Employer to plan administrator, within 30 days of the event. Not required where the employer is also the plan administrator — but the internal handoff should still be documented and timed.
For divorce, legal separation, and a child aging out. The plan must publish reasonable written procedures in the SPD; without them, any reasonable communication of the event is sufficient.
The high-risk document. Within 14 days of receiving notice of the event, or 44 days from the event where the employer is also the plan administrator. It must contain every required content item and be understandable to the average participant.
When someone claims a right to COBRA or an extension and the plan determines they are not entitled. It must explain why. Skipping it is a frequent and entirely unnecessary failure.
Whenever coverage ends before the maximum period. State the termination date, the reason, and any conversion or alternative coverage rights.
Running from the later of the loss of coverage or the date the election notice is furnished. A beneficiary who waives may revoke before the 60 days expire; coverage is then prospective from the revocation.
From the date of election, covering the full period back to the loss of coverage. Together with the election window, a plan can wait up to 105 days before it knows whether coverage exists.
Payment is timely if postmarked within the grace period. Coverage may not be terminated before it runs; claims may be suspended in the gap so long as coverage is reinstated retroactively.
The applicable premium is the full cost for similarly situated active employees, employer and employee shares combined, plus 2 percent. Months 19–29 of a disability extension may be charged at 150 percent.
The retroactive coverage gap is a feature, not a bug. During the election and payment window the individual is in limbo and providers may be told coverage is inactive. Once election and payment are made, coverage is reinstated retroactively with no gap. Most COBRA complaints that reach a broker are really confusion about this window — train your service team to explain it in one clear paragraph.
Outsourcing does not transfer legal responsibility. Most employers use a TPA, payroll platform, or carrier to issue notices — sound practice, but the employer remains the plan sponsor and usually the plan administrator of record. If the vendor sends a notice late because the employer sent the termination file late, the exposure is the employer’s. When auditing a vendor, ask for a fully populated real-scenario election notice, a per-individual mailing record produced on demand years later, and what the service agreement actually says about notice failures — many cap liability at fees paid.
New York’s continuation rights are broader than federal COBRA in two respects that materially change administration for employers with New York-situs insured plans.
New York’s law applies to insured group health plans issued in New York regardless of employer size — so employers under 20 employees, outside federal COBRA entirely, must still offer continuation.
Continuation extends to a total of 36 months, including for events carrying only 18 months federally. In practice: 18 months of federal COBRA followed by an additional state period, up to 36 months in total.
State insurance law reaches the insurance contract. Self-funded ERISA plans are preempted and follow federal COBRA alone — a distinction that matters when moving from fully insured to level-funded or self-funded.
Separate from continuation: young adults aging out of a parent’s New York-insured plan at 26 may purchase coverage through age 29 at the group rate plus an administrative charge, subject to eligibility conditions.
One unsettled question worth putting to your carrier in writing. Where federal COBRA applies first, practitioners are split on when the New York extension must be elected — some carriers treat it as continuing or electable at the point federal COBRA is exhausted, others take the position that the election must be made at the original qualifying event. The statute is not explicit and carrier practice governs in the real world. Confirm the procedure, state it in your election materials, and do not let a departing employee discover the answer at month 18.
If you have employees in more than one state, the picture multiplies. Mini-COBRA laws differ substantially in duration, size thresholds, election windows, and premium limits — an employer with staff in New York, New Jersey, Connecticut, and Pennsylvania is administering four continuation regimes on top of federal COBRA. Maintain a state-by-state matrix and revisit it whenever you add a location.
Why employers bring COBRA to GCI: COBRA is a documentation discipline, and it is one of the areas where an experienced broker adds the most measurable value. Group Coverage, Inc. determines which of your benefits are subject, reads your general and election notices against the current regulatory content requirements, selects and supervises administrators, verifies the 102 and 150 percent calculations at renewal, and aligns federal COBRA with New York’s 36-month insured continuation right — one broker, one renewal calendar, since 1997.
For the primary sources, see the U.S. Department of Labor on continuation coverage and the current model notices, the IRS on the section 4980B excise tax and Form 8928, and the New York State Department of Financial Services on insured continuation requirements.
Not when the termination happened — when the notice was mailed, and to which addresses. That single measurement tells you more about your COBRA exposure than any policy document. Group Coverage, Inc. will review your notice package, your administrator arrangement, and your New York continuation coordination at no cost.
This article is for general educational purposes and is not legal or tax advice. COBRA requirements, notice content standards, indexed penalty amounts, and state continuation rules change and vary by employer size, plan funding arrangement, and jurisdiction. Review your plan documents and notices, or speak with a licensed advisor or qualified counsel, to understand how these concepts apply to your plan.
© 2026 Group Coverage, Inc. All rights reserved.
