Deer Park, NY
Client portal coming soon
Our online client portal is on the way. In the meantime, our team is happy to help — just reach out.
Contact us
One background check on a Long Island hire can be governed by four separate regimes at once. Each has its own notices, its own timing, and its own penalties — and none of them substitutes for the others.
A single background check on a Long Island hire can be governed by four separate regimes at once — the federal FCRA, New York Correction Law Article 23-A, the Clean Slate Act, and, for anyone working in the five boroughs, the NYC Fair Chance Act. Each has its own notices, timing, and penalties, and none substitutes for the others. Two recent changes make most existing templates non-compliant: Clean Slate requires notices to every applicant whose report contains criminal history, even when you intend to hire them; and as of April 18, 2026, New York has banned employer use of consumer credit history outright, statewide. In screening litigation, plaintiffs rarely argue you reached the wrong conclusion. They argue the form was defective — and because the defect is in the form, every applicant shares it.
New York has moved twice in the last two years in ways that change everyday practice. The Clean Slate Act, effective November 16, 2024, requires notices to every applicant whose report contains criminal history — even when you intend to hire them. And as of April 18, 2026, New York State has banned employer use of consumer credit history outright, statewide. If your screening package and adverse action templates predate those dates, they are out of compliance now.
The most expensive mistake is procedural. Plaintiffs argue that the disclosure was not a standalone document, that the pre-adverse action notice was skipped, that no reasonable time was allowed to respond, or that the required New York notices were not delivered. FCRA statutory damages run from $100 to $1,000 per violation for willful noncompliance, plus punitive damages and fees — and because the defect is in the form, every applicant shares it.
Whenever you use a third-party consumer reporting agency — which is almost always — the federal sequence is mandatory and strictly ordered.
A clear and conspicuous written disclosure, in a document consisting solely of that disclosure, stating that a consumer report may be obtained for employment purposes. Courts have found violations where employers added liability waivers, state-law notices, or at-will language to the same page.
Written authorization from the applicant. It may appear on the same document as the disclosure — this is the one permitted addition.
You certify that you made the disclosure, obtained authorization, and will comply with the adverse action requirements and applicable anti-discrimination law.
Before taking adverse action based in whole or in part on the report: provide a copy of the report and the CFPB's summary of rights, and allow a reasonable period to respond. Five business days is the widely used floor; New York City requires more.
After the decision: notify the applicant, identify the CRA by name, address, and phone, state that the CRA did not make the decision and cannot explain it, and disclose the right to a free file copy within 60 days and the right to dispute accuracy.
Two points employers miss. First, the sequence applies to current employees as well as applicants whenever you obtain a report for promotion, reassignment, or retention. Second, “adverse action based in part on the report” is broad: if the report contributed at all, the sequence is required, even where other reasons existed.
New York prohibits denying employment because of a prior criminal conviction unless one of two findings applies: there is a direct relationship between the offense and the specific license or employment sought, or employment would involve an unreasonable risk to property or to the safety or welfare of specific individuals or the general public. Reaching either finding requires an individualized analysis of eight statutory factors: New York’s public policy of encouraging employment of people with criminal records; the specific duties of the job; the bearing the offense has on fitness to perform them; time elapsed since the offense; the person’s age at the time; the seriousness of the offense; any evidence of rehabilitation and good conduct; and your legitimate interest in protecting property and safety.
A Certificate of Relief from Disabilities or a Certificate of Good Conduct creates a presumption of rehabilitation that must be given weight. An applicant denied on the basis of a conviction may request a written statement of reasons, which must be provided within 30 days. Separately, the New York State Human Rights Law makes it unlawful to ask about or act upon arrests not resulting in conviction, sealed convictions, or youthful offender adjudications.
Document the analysis contemporaneously. An Article 23-A defense reconstructed after a complaint is filed is worth considerably less than a dated memorandum already in the file.
Whenever an employer receives criminal history information about an applicant or employee, it must provide that individual with a copy of the information received, notice of the right to seek correction, and a copy of Article 23-A. This applies regardless of whether you take any adverse action — a significant change from prior practice.
Eligible misdemeanor convictions generally three years after release or sentencing; eligible felonies generally eight years, provided the individual is not under supervision and has no pending charges. Sex offenses requiring registration, Class A felonies, and certain other serious offenses are excluded.
The automatic sealing is being implemented on a phased schedule by the court system, with the rollout extending into 2027. The notice obligations, by contrast, have been in effect since November 2024.
Sealed convictions may not be considered and generally should not appear in a compliant report. Do not act on it — and ask your vendor how it was returned.
Update the template, not just the process. Most employers still send Article 23-A only with a pre-adverse action letter. Under Clean Slate, the packet goes to every individual whose report contains criminal history — including the person you are about to hire. Build it into the standard post-report step so it does not depend on anyone remembering. And note what did not change: Clean Slate does not alter the Article 23-A analysis, the NYC Fair Chance Act, or the federal FCRA. All continue to apply on top of it.
Employers with four or more employees and any worker in New York City face the strictest regime in the state. The Fair Chance Act amends the NYC Human Rights Law and is enforced by the Commission on Human Rights.
The 2021 amendments extended coverage to current employees and to pending arrests and criminal accusations, and added a separate multi-factor analysis for pending matters.
This is the newest and most operationally significant change. On December 19, 2025, Governor Hochul signed S3072, amending the New York State Fair Credit Reporting Act (General Business Law § 380 et seq.). Effective April 18, 2026, it is an unlawful discriminatory practice for an employer, labor organization, employment agency, or their agents to request or use an applicant’s or employee’s consumer credit history for employment purposes, or to discriminate based on it in hiring, compensation, or the terms, conditions, or privileges of employment.
“Consumer credit history” is defined broadly — creditworthiness, credit standing, credit capacity, or payment history, as reflected in a credit report or score, or obtained directly from the individual regarding credit accounts, bankruptcies, judgments, or liens. Asking the candidate directly is covered. Consumer reporting agencies may not furnish credit information to employers for employment purposes unless an exemption applies, so your vendor’s package must change, not just your policy. Narrow exemptions exist, including where a law requires the check, for certain positions involving signatory authority over significant funds or assets, and for positions with responsibility for digital security systems.
New York City’s exemptions are narrower, and the narrower test governs there. Under the Stop Credit Discrimination in Employment Act, in force since September 2015, the exemptions for positions involving $10,000 or more in funds and for digital security responsibilities apply only to executive-level positions. The State law expressly does not preempt more protective local law, so NYC employers must satisfy both. Employers relying on an SCDEA exemption must maintain records supporting it.
Three things to do now. First, instruct your screening vendor in writing to remove credit history from every New York package unless a documented exemption applies. Second, delete credit-related questions from applications and interview guides — asking the candidate is prohibited too. Third, if you believe a role is exempt, document which exemption and why before you order the report, applying the narrower New York City test for any position based in the five boroughs.
Order MVRs only for roles that actually drive, obtain FCRA consent, and set a written eligibility standard applied consistently. In New York, employers with drivers commonly enroll in the DMV’s License Event Notification Service, which pushes notice of license status changes rather than requiring periodic manual pulls. Your auto carrier will generally require MVRs at hire and annually.
A commercial database search returning names and addresses historically associated with a number. It tells the screener where to search for records. It is not identity verification, not proof of work authorization, and not a substitute for Form I-9. Do not reject a candidate because a trace looks unusual — database gaps are common and disproportionately affect people who have moved, married, or recently immigrated.
Every employer must complete Form I-9 within three business days of the start date and retain it for the longer of three years after hire or one year after termination. New York does not require private employers to use E-Verify. If you use it voluntarily, apply it uniformly to all new hires — selective use is a discrimination claim.
Verify professional licenses at the primary source — the issuing board — not through a database aggregator. For healthcare and human services employers, also screen the federal exclusion lists (HHS OIG LEIE and SAM) and applicable New York registries at hire and on a recurring schedule, since exclusion can occur after hire.
Salary history is prohibited statewide — you may not ask about or rely on a candidate’s compensation history. Pay transparency requires job advertisements for roles performed at least in part in New York to disclose a good-faith compensation range and the job description if one exists. Cannabis is protected under Labor Law § 201-d for lawful recreational use outside work hours, off employer premises, and without employer equipment; employers generally may not test for cannabis or act on a positive result, subject to narrow exceptions including where required by federal law or a federal contract, or where the employee is impaired at work — so remove cannabis from standard panels for New York roles unless a specific exception applies. New York law generally bars employers from requesting usernames, passwords, or access to personal social media accounts. And marital, familial, and domestic violence victim status are protected characteristics under the State Human Rights Law — a reminder that what a report incidentally reveals can create exposure even where you never acted on it.
Why employers bring screening to GCI: background screening sits where hiring practice, insurance underwriting, and employment liability meet — which is why it belongs in a broker conversation and not only a legal one. Group Coverage, Inc. designs screening packages matched to each role so you order what the position justifies and nothing that creates unnecessary exposure, confirms your consumer reporting agency’s New York packages reflect Clean Slate and the April 2026 credit ban, reviews standalone disclosures, authorizations, Clean Slate packets, and adverse action letters, builds driver programs with MVR standards and LENS enrollment, handles credential monitoring and exclusion list screening for healthcare clients, and aligns your hiring practices with the EPLI coverage that responds when a claim arrives.
For the primary sources, see the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau on the FCRA and the summary of rights, the New York State Division of Human Rights on Article 23-A and protected characteristics, and the NYC Commission on Human Rights on the Fair Chance Act and the Stop Credit Discrimination in Employment Act.
No waiver, no at-will language, no state notices bundled in. That one question decides whether your defect is individual or classwide. Group Coverage, Inc. will review your screening program, vendor packages, and adverse action templates against Clean Slate and the April 2026 credit ban, and align them with your EPLI coverage — at no cost.
This article is for general educational purposes and is not legal advice. Screening obligations, notice content requirements, sealing schedules, exemptions, and statutory damages change and vary by employer size, role, and jurisdiction — and local law may be more protective than State law. Review your screening program and vendor packages, or speak with a licensed advisor or qualified employment counsel, before acting on any item discussed here.
© 2026 Group Coverage, Inc. All rights reserved.
