Deer Park, NY
Client portal coming soon
Our online client portal is on the way. In the meantime, our team is happy to help — just reach out.
Contact us
These three accounts all let employees pay medical costs with pre-tax dollars. That is where the similarity ends — and getting the combination wrong does not produce a warning message. It produces a taxable event years later.
HSAs, FSAs, and HRAs all let employees pay medical costs with pre-tax dollars. That is where the similarity ends — and getting the combination wrong does not produce a warning message, it produces a taxable event years later. Two changes reset the field for 2026: the One Big Beautiful Bill Act made bronze and catastrophic plans HSA-qualifying, made telehealth relief permanent, and stopped direct primary care from disqualifying eligibility; and the dependent care limit rose from $5,000 to $7,500 — an increase that is not automatic if your cafeteria plan states the limit as a dollar figure. Check your HDHP deductible against next year’s floor before you sign a renewal, and confirm no HSA participant sits under a general-purpose health FSA, including through a spouse.
The three account types differ on who owns the money, who funds it, what happens to an unspent balance, whether the employee can be enrolled in anything else, and which of them can coexist. Those differences are not cosmetic — they determine the tax result.
Permanently and portably. Requires a qualifying HDHP and no disqualifying coverage. Balances roll over forever, survive termination, and carry triple tax treatment: pre-tax in, tax-free growth, tax-free out for qualified expenses. Only deposited funds are available.
Funded mostly by salary reduction, with no HDHP requirement. Use-or-lose, subject to a carryover or grace period. The full annual election is available on day one under the uniform coverage rule — which is the employer’s risk.
A notional account; employees may never contribute. Whether it rolls over, and whether it survives termination, is whatever the plan says. ICHRA requires individual coverage; a standard integrated HRA generally disqualifies HSA eligibility.
An HSA participant also covered by a general-purpose health FSA — often through a spouse’s plan. That FSA is disqualifying coverage, and every HSA contribution made while it is in force is an excess contribution subject to a 6% excise tax for each year it remains. The fix is a limited-purpose FSA restricted to dental, vision, and post-deductible expenses.
Check the spouse’s plan, not just your own enrollment. Disqualifying coverage most often arrives through a household rather than through your census. Nothing in your enrollment system will catch it, and nothing will flag it at the time — the employee discovers it when they file, or when the IRS does.
To contribute, an individual must be covered by a qualifying HDHP on the first day of the month, have no other disqualifying coverage — including a general-purpose health FSA, most HRAs, TRICARE, or enrollment in any part of Medicare — and not be claimed as a dependent on someone else’s return. Dental, vision, disability, long-term care, specific disease, fixed indemnity, workers’ compensation, a limited-purpose FSA, and a post-deductible HRA are all permitted alongside.
2026: $4,400 self-only, $8,750 family. 2027: $4,500 and $9,000. The age-55 catch-up is $1,000 in both years.
2026: $1,700 self-only / $3,400 family. 2027: $1,750 / $3,500 — the figure to check before renewal.
2026: $8,500 / $17,000. 2027: $8,700 / $17,400. These sit below the ACA maximums for the same year; a plan must satisfy both, so the HSA figure governs.
Excepted benefit HRA: $2,200 for 2026, $2,250 for 2027. Direct primary care fees: $150 individual / $300 family per month — not indexed upward for 2027.
If your HDHP deductible sits exactly at the current minimum, it must rise for 2027. At least $1,750 self-only or $3,500 family — otherwise the plan stops qualifying as an HDHP and nobody enrolled in it may contribute to an HSA. This is a renewal-season check that costs nothing and prevents a plan-wide problem.
And it does not step up again. Each spouse who is 55 or older needs their own HSA to make their own catch-up contribution — it cannot be combined into one account.
A married couple divides the $8,750 as they choose, plus separate catch-ups. It is not $8,750 each.
Someone eligible on December 1 may contribute the full annual amount for that year — but losing eligibility before the end of the following December makes the excess taxable, plus a 10% penalty.
Enrollment in any part of Medicare disqualifies further contributions, and Part A enrollment can be backdated up to six months. Employees working past 65 should stop contributions roughly six months before they enroll.
Distributions drive the tax result, not the timing of the expense — provided the expense was incurred after the HSA was established and the receipt is kept. Form 8889 is filed every year there is a contribution or distribution.
How you fund HSAs determines which nondiscrimination regime applies. Contributions made through a Section 125 cafeteria plan are subject to the cafeteria plan rules but escape the comparability rules — which is why nearly all employers fund HSAs through the cafeteria plan. Contributions made outside one are subject to the comparable contribution rules, requiring the same amount or the same percentage of deductible for all comparable participating employees, with a 35% excise tax on the aggregate amount contributed for failures. If you contribute outside a cafeteria plan, verify comparability testing annually.
The One Big Beautiful Bill Act, signed July 4, 2025, produced the most significant expansion of HSA eligibility since the accounts were created. The IRS implemented it in Notice 2026-05.
An HDHP may cover telehealth and other remote care before the deductible without disqualifying HSA contributions — permanently, for plan years beginning on or after January 1, 2025. The safe harbor covers the remote consultation itself, not in-person services, equipment, or drugs furnished in connection with it.
As of January 1, 2026, they count as HDHPs regardless of whether they meet the general deductible and out-of-pocket definitions, and whether or not purchased through an Exchange. This makes ICHRA plus a bronze plan plus employee HSA contributions a coherent design for the first time.
An individual in a qualifying DPC arrangement — periodic fees up to $150 monthly individual, $300 family — remains HSA-eligible, and HSA funds may pay those fees.
Plan documents that still condition pre-deductible telehealth on a temporary extension; payroll and enrollment screens that block HSA elections for anyone in a DPC arrangement; and open enrollment communications, which in most organizations still describe the pre-2026 rules.
The 2026 health FSA salary reduction limit is $3,400 — per employee, not per household, so each working spouse may elect the full amount. Maximum carryover into the next plan year is $680. A plan may offer a carryover or a grace period of up to two and a half months, but not both — and offering a grace period on a general-purpose health FSA also blocks HSA eligibility for the entire grace period, which is a frequent and expensive interaction.
Test in the third quarter, not in December. The 55% average benefits test is where dependent care plans most often fail, because highly compensated employees use them at much higher rates. Testing performed at year end leaves exactly one remedy: reclassifying benefits as taxable income for your highest-paid employees, in December, after they have already spent the money. A mid-year projection using actual participation lets you correct through communication and enrollment changes while the plan year is still running.
Five HRA designs cover nearly every situation. An integrated HRA pairs employer funding with your own group plan and generally disqualifies HSA eligibility unless built as limited-purpose or post-deductible. An ICHRA reimburses individual market premiums instead of offering a group plan, with no dollar cap, but requires permitted classes on uniform terms, verification of individual coverage, an annual opt-out, and written notice at least 90 days before the plan year. An EBHRA sits alongside a group plan the employee need not enroll in, capped at $2,200 for 2026 and $2,250 for 2027, and does not disqualify HSA eligibility if designed correctly. A QSEHRA serves employers that are not ALEs and offer no group plan, at $6,450 self-only / $13,100 family for 2026. A retiree HRA funds retiree medical expenses and, standalone, is exempt from many market reform rules.
All HRAs share three features worth stating plainly: they are employer-funded only, they are notional rather than funded accounts unless you choose to fund them, and they are group health plans — which means ERISA plan documents, SPDs, COBRA, HIPAA privacy, and PCORI fees all apply. Employers frequently treat an HRA as a payroll practice. It is not.
Four tests apply, and they cover different things. Section 125 eligibility, benefits, and contributions testing checks that the cafeteria plan does not favour highly compensated individuals in who may participate or in what they receive. Section 125 key employee concentration checks that key employees do not receive more than 25% of the aggregate nontaxable benefits. Section 105(h) applies to self-insured health plans and health FSAs; failure makes excess reimbursements taxable to highly compensated individuals. Section 129 covers dependent care FSAs, including the 55% average benefits test and the 5% owner concentration test.
Federal pre-tax treatment does not automatically carry through to state income tax, and for employers operating across the New York metropolitan area the gap is wider than most realize. New York generally conforms to the federal treatment of cafeteria plan and HSA contributions. New Jersey does not. New Jersey and California are the only two states that do not follow the federal HSA treatment: HSA contributions — employee and employer — are subject to New Jersey gross income tax, account earnings are taxable, and the employer contribution reported in Box 12 Code W is added back on the NJ-1040. New Jersey also taxes health FSA salary reductions: per Technical Bulletin TB-39R, a benefit funded through a salary reduction agreement does not meet New Jersey’s requirements for exclusion, so the employee’s full salary without reduction is subject to New Jersey tax and withholding.
This goes wrong in payroll configuration, not in plan design. If you have employees in more than one state, ask your payroll provider to confirm in writing how each account type is treated in each state — then verify it against a live pay stub rather than a setup screen. A New Jersey resident’s state wages should be visibly higher than their federal wages. If they are not, the setup is wrong.
Why employers bring account-based plans to GCI: small design decisions here produce outsized tax consequences. Group Coverage, Inc. models HSA, FSA, and HRA combinations against your actual workforce — including ICHRA and the 2026 bronze-plus-HSA structures — maintains plan documents and communications as the indexed figures change, verifies deductibles and out-of-pocket maximums against next year’s thresholds before you sign a renewal, evaluates administrators and their substantiation practices, coordinates mid-year and year-end nondiscrimination testing, confirms multi-state payroll treatment account by account, and explains the HSA/FSA interaction and Medicare timing to employees before it causes a problem.
For the primary sources, see the Internal Revenue Service on HSA and HDHP limits, Notice 2026-05, and Forms 8889 and 2441, the U.S. Department of Labor on HRA and ICHRA notice requirements, and the New Jersey Division of Taxation on the state treatment of cafeteria plan and HSA amounts.
$1,750 self-only, $3,500 family. If it sits exactly at this year’s floor, the plan stops qualifying and nobody in it can contribute to an HSA. Group Coverage, Inc. will run an account design and compliance review — deductibles, disqualifying coverage, plan document limits, and multi-state payroll treatment — before your next renewal, at no cost.
This article is for general educational purposes and is not legal or tax advice. Contribution limits, HDHP thresholds, indexed figures, and state conformity rules change annually and vary by plan design, funding arrangement, and jurisdiction. Review your plan documents and confirm current figures, or speak with a licensed advisor or qualified tax counsel, to understand how these concepts apply to your plan.
© 2026 Group Coverage, Inc. All rights reserved.
